A therapist and client in a modern office setting, engaged in a counseling session. erp therapy

ERP Therapy vs. DBT Therapy: Understanding the Uses and Differences

March 24, 2025

Dr. Matthew Mandelbaum

Navigating mental health challenges can be overwhelming, especially when trying to find the right therapeutic approach. Exposure and Response Prevention (ERP) therapy and Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT) are two evidence-based treatments used to help individuals manage mental health disorders effectively.

Both therapies are powerful tools in the field of psychology, but each has unique strengths designed to address specific conditions.

This guide will unpack what ERP and DBT are, their techniques, and how to determine which one might be the best fit for you or your loved one.

What is Exposure and Response Prevention Therapy?

Exposure and Response Prevention (ERP) therapy, an offshoot of cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT), is considered the gold standard treatment to treat obsessive compulsive disorder (OCD). It is also effective for anxiety-related disorders, such as panic disorder, social anxiety, and body dysmorphic disorder.

How Does ERP Work?

Response prevention therapy, specifically exposure and response prevention therapy (ERP), focuses on confronting feared stimuli in a cautious and therapeutic environment while preventing the compulsive behaviors or rituals that may follow.

By doing so, individuals gradually train their brain to respond differently to triggers, reducing avoidance behaviors and distress over time.

Principles of Inhibitory Learning

Step-by-Step Approach

ERP therapy follows a structured, step-by-step approach to help individuals manage their OCD symptoms effectively. Here’s a general outline of the steps involved:

Initial Assessment: The therapist conducts a comprehensive assessment to understand the individual’s OCD symptoms, including the specific obsessions and compulsions they experience.
Creating an Exposure Hierarchy: Together, the therapist and the individual create an exposure hierarchy—a ranked list of anxiety-triggering situations or stimuli, ordered from least to most challenging.
Exposure: The individual begins exposure to the first item on the hierarchy. The therapist supports them in processing their anxiety and preventing their automatic compulsive response.
Response Prevention: The individual is guided to refrain from engaging in their compulsive behaviors, learning instead to tolerate the anxiety associated with their obsessions.
Processing and Reflection: After each exposure session, the individual reflects on their experience, with the therapist helping to identify any emerging patterns or themes.
Gradual Progression: The individual gradually moves up the hierarchy, facing increasingly challenging situations or stimuli, and learning to manage higher levels of anxiety.
Maintenance and Relapse Prevention: The therapist provides strategies for maintaining progress and preventing relapse, offering ongoing support and guidance.

This step-by-step approach ensures that individuals can systematically confront and manage their OCD symptoms, leading to long-term improvement and better quality of life.

Techniques Used in Treating OCD with ERP Therapy

Imaginal Exposure: Patients are asked to repeatedly imagine scenarios related to their intrusive thoughts or feared outcomes. For instance, someone with contamination OCD might mentally explore the experience of touching a public restroom door handle.

In Vivo Exposure: This involves facing real-life situations that trigger anxiety or compulsions. For example, an individual with ritualistic behavior like repeatedly washing their hands might practice touching a “dirty” surface and not washing afterward.

Response Prevention Techniques: The goal is to engage in response prevention, stopping the compulsions tied to the feared situation. This is done gradually and at a pace set by the therapist to ensure inhibitory learning over time.

ERP therapy requires the guidance of a trained clinician with specialized training to ensure the treatment process is effective and supportive. Integrating cognitive therapy components into ERP can enhance its effectiveness by addressing the underlying cognitive distortions.

Who Can Benefit from ERP Therapy?

ERP therapy is particularly effective for individuals with obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD), especially those who:

Experience severe OCD symptoms that significantly impact their daily life
Have not found success with other treatments, such as medication or cognitive-behavioral therapy
Are motivated to change their behavior and willing to face their fears
Have a supportive network of family or friends to provide encouragement throughout the treatment process

Beyond OCD, ERP therapy can also benefit individuals with other anxiety-related disorders, including post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), social anxiety disorder, and specific phobias. Its structured approach helps individuals confront and manage their anxiety, leading to significant improvements in their overall mental health.

Finding the Right Therapist

Selecting the right therapist is crucial for the success of ERP therapy. When searching for a therapist, consider the following factors:

Experience: Look for a therapist with a proven track record of working with individuals who have OCD and anxiety-related disorders.
Training: Ensure the therapist has specialized training in ERP therapy and cognitive-behavioral therapy.
Approach: Choose a therapist who adopts a collaborative and supportive approach, working with you to develop a personalized treatment plan.
Availability: Find a therapist whose availability aligns with your schedule and who can provide consistent support and guidance throughout the treatment process.

A well-matched therapist can make a significant difference in your treatment outcomes, helping you navigate the challenges of ERP therapy effectively.

What to Expect from Therapy

ERP therapy is a powerful treatment for OCD, but it can be challenging and uncomfortable at times. Here’s what to expect from the therapy process:

Initial Anxiety: It’s normal to feel anxious or uncomfortable when starting therapy. This initial anxiety will decrease as you become more familiar with the process.
Gradual Progress: Progress in ERP therapy is gradual. While it may feel slow at times, consistent effort and practice will lead to significant improvements in your symptoms.
Support and Guidance: Your therapist will provide ongoing support and guidance, helping you develop strategies to maintain your progress and prevent relapse.
Personalized Approach: ERP therapy is tailored to your unique needs and goals. Your therapist will work with you to create a treatment plan that addresses your specific challenges and objectives.

Understanding what to expect can help you approach ERP therapy with realistic expectations and a commitment to the process, ultimately leading to better outcomes and improved mental health.

man in blue dress shirt sitting on yellow chair

What is DBT in Cognitive Behavioral Therapy?

Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT) was originally developed for individuals with borderline personality disorder (BPD) but has since been shown to be highly effective for a wide range of mental health issues.

These include emotional dysregulation, severe stress, post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), and panic disorder.

How Does DBT Work?

DBT focuses on four main areas of skill-building to help individuals improve their emotional regulation, handle stress, and enhance interpersonal relationships.

Techniques Used in DBT Therapy

Mindfulness: This practice involves staying present in the moment, recognizing emotions without judgment, and reducing emotional reactivity.
Distress Tolerance: Distress tolerance teaches strategies for coping with crisis situations or intense emotions, such as breathing exercises or grounding techniques.
Emotion Regulation: DBT helps individuals understand their emotions, the role of their triggers, and how to regain calmness when overwhelmed.
Interpersonal Effectiveness: These skills assist people in building healthy, meaningful relationships while setting boundaries effectively.

DBT’s structured approach makes it especially helpful for those needing support with impulse control or navigating conflict-ridden relationships.

Key Differences Between ERP and DBT

Although ERP and DBT are both types of behavioral therapy, they differ in their goals, techniques, and the mental health conditions they address.

Goals and Focus

ERP: ERP therapy is laser-focused on treating OCD by breaking cycles of compulsive behaviors and reducing avoidance related to OCD symptoms and other anxiety disorders. The primary aim is to retrain the brain’s fear response through repeated exposure.
DBT: DBT focuses on building emotional resilience and interpersonal skills. Its objective is to teach individuals how to manage intense emotions while improving overall life skills.

Techniques Used

ERP emphasizes exposure therapy, response prevention techniques, and systematic desensitization.
DBT incorporates mindfulness exercises, cognitive behavior therapy, and skills training to address everyday challenges.

Conditions Treated

ERP specializes in addressing OCD, severe anxiety, compulsive behaviors, and related disorders like contamination OCD or body dysmorphic disorder. Relapse prevention planning is crucial as the concluding phase of ERP therapy, where strategies are discussed to help patients avoid a return of their OCD symptoms after treatment.

DBT is ideal for individuals with borderline personality traits, post-traumatic stress disorder, or those needing help with emotional regulation issues.

woman in black long sleeve shirt holding black ceramic mug

Similarities Between ERP and DBT

Despite their differences, ERP and DBT share some common principles and goals.

Behavioral Change: Both therapies emphasize replacing unhealthy patterns (like compulsions or emotional outbursts) with healthier coping mechanisms.
Therapeutic Relationships: A strong connection with a mental health professional is critical to the success of both therapies. Therapist support fosters trust and commitment to the treatment process.
Holistic Mental Health Benefits: The ultimate aim for both ERP and DBT is to improve an individual’s overall well-being and quality of life.

When to Choose ERP vs. DBT

Choosing between ERP and DBT depends on several factors, including the nature of your symptoms and your treatment goals.

When to Choose ERP: If you struggle with OCD, compulsive behaviors, or repeated fear responses, ERP might be the right fit. ERP is particularly effective for individuals with obsessive thoughts or severe avoidance related to anxiety triggers.
When to Choose DBT: If your challenges lie in stress management, emotional instability, or difficulty navigating relationships, DBT offers valuable tools for building skills in these areas.

Consult a Mental Health Professional

If you’re still unsure about the best option for your mental health needs, a licensed psychologist or ERP therapist can provide personalized recommendations based on your individual behavior therapy goals.

Dr. Matthew G. Mandelbaum’s Approach

For individuals seeking a tailored therapeutic approach, Dr. Matthew G. Mandelbaum blends DBT with trauma-informed care to enhance stress management and emotional resilience. With over 43 states where telepsychology services are available, his practice offers options that fit your schedule and location.

Contact Groundbreaker Therapy today to explore customized treatment plans that align with your mental health goals. Whether you’re curious about DBT techniques or navigating challenges with ERP treatment, we’re here to guide you through the treatment plan that works for you.

two women sitting beside table and talking

Finding the Right Solution for Your Mental Health

Both ERP and DBT are evidence-based tools that offer significant improvement for people struggling with mental disorders. While ERP helps treat OCD and anxiety disorders, DBT focuses on improving emotional regulation and interpersonal skills.

By understanding the treatment outcomes and benefits of each approach, you can decide what works best for your needs or the needs of your loved ones.

If you’re ready to take the next step, consider consulting with a licensed mental health professional to create a treatment plan tailored to your unique goals. Share this guide with someone you know who may benefit from understanding these therapeutic options.