Groundbreaker Therapy does not conduct paid clinical studies, paid research studies, or compensated clinical trials.
If you arrived here looking for a paid research study or received information suggesting that we are recruiting participants for compensation, that information is incorrect.
Dr. Matthew Mandelbaum provides private psychotherapy services only. We are not currently enrolling participants for paid research studies or compensated clinical trials.
Success is the accomplishment of an aim or purpose—but that definition only works when the aim reflects your actual values. When achievement stops feeling meaningful, it often signals a mismatch between what you’ve been taught to pursue and what genuinely matters to you. Redefining success is not about lowering your standards. It’s about understanding what you’re actually building and why.
You worked for years to get here. The promotion came through. The income milestone passed. The business grew. And then, somewhere between the congratulations and the next quarterly goal, you noticed something unexpected: it didn’t feel the way you thought it would.
Ready to Start Therapy?
Your healing journey can begin today. Fill out the form below to connect with a therapist who truly listens and understands.
Not devastating. Not hollow exactly. Just… less.
That moment of quiet deflation—after achieving something genuinely difficult—is one of the most disorienting experiences high-achieving people describe. It doesn’t make logical sense. You did what you were supposed to do. You put in the hard work, you completed the challenging projects, you earned the recognition. So why does the finish line feel like just another starting block?
This isn’t a sign that something is wrong with you. It’s often a sign that the definition of success you’ve been operating from may not have been yours to begin with.
As a licensed psychologist who works with highly accomplished individuals—executives, entrepreneurs, professionals, and others navigating complex questions about identity, meaning, and direction—I’ve sat with this question many times. What follows is an exploration of what success actually means, where our definitions come from, and how to build a more intentional relationship with achievement.
How Do We Define Success?
The word “success” sounds objective. Reach the goal, win the prize, get the title. But the moment you try to define success precisely, it becomes surprisingly personal.
At its simplest, success is the accomplishment of an aim or purpose. But that definition raises an immediate follow-up: Who decided which aims were worth pursuing?
Success has different meanings for different people—and those meanings are far more varied than professional culture tends to acknowledge. One person may define success through career advancement and financial security. Another may prioritize autonomy, creative work, or deep relationships. For someone else, success means time with family, freedom from chronic stress, or steady personal growth.
There is no universal psychological formula for a successful life. A useful definition of success should reflect the individual’s actual priorities—not simply the markers their environment taught them to pursue.
Success encompasses multiple dimensions beyond just money or achievement. It can include autonomy, contribution, peace, mastery, relationships, and personal growth. Understanding which of those dimensions genuinely motivates you is where meaningful self-discovery begins.
Helpful resource: American Psychological Association — Positive Psychology and Well-Being explores well-being as something broader than accomplishment alone, including positive emotion, engagement, relationships, meaning, and achievement.
Where Did Your Definition of Success Come From?
Most people never consciously choose their definition of success. They absorb it.
From family: A family may communicate—explicitly or through years of subtle messaging—that success means financial security, a prestigious profession, owning a business, marriage, children, or avoiding the financial struggles previous generations experienced. These messages land early and run deep.
From school and education: School reinforces the idea that achievement means high grades, competitive college admissions, a respected college degree, awards, and measurable progress. The education system is particularly effective at teaching people to optimize for external evaluation. Many high achievers spend decades doing exactly that without realizing it.
From career and professional culture: Professions have their own internal hierarchies. Promotions, titles, compensation, recognition, billable hours, deals closed—these become the informal scorecard that determines whether someone is “on track.” The problem isn’t that these metrics exist. The problem arises when someone accepts them as personal values without examination.
From the wider world: Culture often connects being successful with amassing wealth, fame, visibility, status, and constant productivity. Busyness itself becomes a badge of honor. Achievement is celebrated; rest is treated with suspicion.
None of these influences are automatically harmful. The psychological problem occurs when someone follows them automatically—without asking whether they still fit. Defining success requires introspection and self-awareness, and many accomplished people have spent far more time building their careers than examining the values underneath them.
Achieving Success Can Feel Surprisingly Empty
For many high achievers, achievement operates through a predictable cycle:
- Identify the next goal.
- Work intensely toward it.
- Achieve it.
- Experience brief relief or satisfaction.
- Immediately identify the next goal.
Over time, that cycle can become less about moving toward something genuinely meaningful and more about managing the discomfort of stopping. Progress becomes the point. The destination becomes almost irrelevant.
Someone can become extraordinarily skilled at pursuing goals without regularly pausing to evaluate whether those goals still matter. The result is a person who is exceptionally capable—and increasingly uncertain whether the ladder they’re climbing is leaning against the right wall.
If any of this resonates, consider these questions honestly:
- What did I expect this achievement to make me feel?
- How long did that feeling actually last?
- What am I hoping the next accomplishment will finally provide?
- Do I enjoy the process, or only the moment of completion?
- Would I still want this if nobody else knew I achieved it?
These aren’t rhetorical questions. They’re the beginning of a more honest relationship with your own ambition.
Helpful resource: PubMed — The Challenge of Staying Happier: Testing the Hedonic Adaptation Prevention Model examines how the boost in happiness following a positive achievement or life change can diminish over time as people adapt and develop new aspirations.
Financial Success Matters—But Money Cannot Answer Every Question
Financial success deserves a nuanced conversation, not a dismissal.
Money can provide safety, opportunity, access to healthcare, educational resources, meaningful experiences, and flexibility over how you spend your time. For someone who grew up with financial insecurity, earning or amassing wealth carries real psychological significance—security that shouldn’t be minimized.
At the same time, money does not automatically resolve questions involving identity, relationships, purpose, belonging, self-worth, or peace. These are separate categories, and conflating them leads to a particular kind of frustration: working harder toward financial goals while wondering why the well-being you expected hasn’t arrived.
A more useful question than “Does money matter?” is: “What do I want money to make possible?”
When the answer is specific—more time with family, geographic freedom, the ability to take creative risks, security for people you love—money becomes a tool with a clear purpose. When the answer is vague, financial success can become an end in itself, a number that keeps growing without ever arriving at satisfaction.
Helpful resource: PNAS — Income and Emotional Well-Being: A Conflict Resolved examines the complicated relationship between income and emotional well-being, showing why money can matter without providing a simple answer to happiness or fulfillment.
Why High Achievers Can Struggle to Know What They Actually Want
High-achieving people are often extraordinarily good at understanding expectations. They know how to get excellent grades, enter competitive programs, build careers, solve difficult problems, complete demanding projects, and meet professional standards others find daunting.
But following a clearly defined path is fundamentally different from deciding what the path should be.
Someone can become successful at accomplishing goals that were never fully chosen. Years later, they may find themselves in a strange position: they know how to achieve almost anything, but they’re less certain what they genuinely want to achieve.
This is not a character flaw. It’s often the predictable result of spending years in systems—school, competitive programs, demanding professions—that reward performance on someone else’s terms. The ability to excel in those systems is real and valuable. But it doesn’t automatically produce clarity about personal direction.
Questions worth sitting with:
- What would I pursue if nobody were evaluating the outcome?
- Which accomplishments genuinely energized me versus simply creating relief?
- What parts of my current life would I protect even if they added nothing to my status?
- What am I afraid would happen if I stopped striving?
That last question, in particular, tends to reveal quite a bit.
Helpful resource: Self-Determination Theory — Goals, Values, and Aspirations explains research distinguishing intrinsic goals such as personal growth, relationships, and contribution from more externally focused goals such as wealth, fame, and approval.
How Does Your Definition of Success Change Over Time?
What felt important at 22 may carry very different weight at 42. A person’s definition of success is not fixed—it evolves through marriage, parenthood, loss, career changes, health challenges, burnout, and the kind of deeper self-understanding that often only comes with time.
Someone may once have defined success as: “I need to prove I can do this.”
Later, it may become: “I want more control over my time.” Or: “I want to be present with my family.” Or: “I want a quieter life.”
These life changes don’t represent failure or retreat. They often reflect growth—a more refined understanding of what actually sustains a person versus what once motivated them. Recognizing that your definition has shifted is not the same as abandoning ambition. It’s an act of honesty.
Common indicators of success evolve too. Career stability, healthy relationships, and inner fulfillment become more prominent as external markers like titles and compensation become less emotionally urgent. This is a normal and healthy progression—when someone allows themselves to notice it.
Personal Growth Can Be a Form of Achieving Success
Personal growth rarely appears on a résumé. But psychologically, it can change a person’s quality of life more profoundly than most promotions.
Examples of genuine growth might include:
- Setting a boundary you previously couldn’t hold
- Repairing a relationship that mattered
- Becoming less reactive under pressure
- Making decisions based on values rather than fear
- Learning to rest without guilt
- Asking for help
- Responding to failure with curiosity rather than shame
- Developing greater self-awareness about patterns that have cost you
None of these show up in performance reviews. But a growth mindset—one that allows improvement through effort, reflection, and learning—is one of the most durable forms of personal development available to anyone.
At Groundbreaker Therapy, the belief underlying this work is that meaningful psychological progress should create visible change outside the therapy room. Understanding yourself more deeply matters. Behaving differently because of what you’ve learned matters more.
Personal Goals vs. Goals You Feel Expected to Have
High achievement and self-awareness don’t always travel together. Someone can be intensely motivated and still be pursuing goals that primarily signal success to other people rather than creating a life they actually want.
This doesn’t mean every such goal should be abandoned. Awareness creates choice—and that’s the point.
When evaluating a goal, consider:
- Do I actually want this, or do I want what it represents?
- What do I expect it to change about my day-to-day life?
- What will pursuing it cost me in time, relationships, or health?
- Would I pursue it if the outcome were invisible to everyone else?
- What happens after I achieve it?
Setting personal and professional goals that genuinely reflect your priorities—rather than inherited expectations—requires this kind of honest evaluation. SMART goal-setting frameworks (specific, measurable, achievable, relevant, and time bound) can provide useful structure. But structure only serves you when it’s pointed in a meaningful direction. A perfectly crafted plan toward the wrong destination is still the wrong destination.
Helpful resource: MindTools — SMART Goals explains the SMART framework for creating goals that are specific, measurable, achievable, relevant, and time-bound while emphasizing the importance of clearly defining what you are trying to accomplish.
How to Find Fulfillment Beyond Achievement
Many accomplished people assume fulfillment will arrive automatically once enough has been achieved. It rarely works that way.
Fulfillment tends to emerge from multiple areas of life simultaneously—not from professional achievement alone. Meaningful relationships, intellectual engagement, contribution to others, creative expression, community, and physical health all play a role. So do less visible things: autonomy, play, rest, time in nature, and the freedom to engage with work you actually care about.
To find fulfillment does not mean abandoning ambition. Someone can remain intensely driven while broadening the sources from which they draw meaning. This tends to make professional achievement healthier—career outcomes no longer carry the full weight of a person’s identity or happiness.
When the question shifts from “What am I accomplishing?” to “What kind of life am I building?”, the answers often open up in ways that feel both more honest and more sustainable.
Helpful resource: Harvard University — Happiness brings together research on happiness, health, relationships, and well-being, including findings from the long-running Harvard Study of Adult Development about the importance of meaningful relationships.
Core Values Can Help Redefine What Success Means
Core values are one of the most practical tools for reexamining success. They differ from goals in an important way: a goal can be completed, while a value provides ongoing direction.
For example:
- Goal: Make partner at the firm.
- Value: Professional mastery.
Someone who holds mastery as a core value may eventually discover there are several paths to living that value—only one of which requires a specific title.
Values might include: intellectual curiosity, integrity, family, creativity, service, independence, contribution, growth, community, freedom, stability, or peace. The list is personal, and there’s no correct answer.
A useful exercise: identify the five values that matter most to you right now. Then ask honestly—How much does my current life actually reflect these values?
The gap between that answer and how you’re spending your time is often where the most important work lives.
Success and Well-Being Don’t Always Move Together
External achievement and internal well-being are not the same thing, and they don’t automatically rise together.
Someone can be objectively successful while experiencing burnout, chronic anxiety, relational disconnection, persistent pressure, or a quiet sense that something essential is missing. These experiences aren’t weaknesses. They’re information.
A sustainable definition of success includes the quality of the life being created while achievements are pursued—not just the achievements themselves. For some people, success eventually comes to mean: working fewer hours, maintaining health, protecting relationships, having the freedom to engage with interests outside work, or creating enough financial security rather than maximizing income indefinitely.
Reducing intensity in one area does not represent failure. For some people, it represents the first genuinely self-determined choice they’ve made in years.
Helpful resource: Gallup — The Five Essential Elements of Well-Being explores career, social, financial, physical, and community well-being as interconnected parts of a thriving life rather than treating professional or financial achievement as the only measure.
What Is the Cost of Your Current Definition of Success?
Every meaningful goal carries a cost. The relevant question is whether the tradeoff remains worthwhile.
Possible costs include time, sleep, relationships, health, family involvement, emotional energy, geographic flexibility, and the opportunity to pursue other long-term goals. These costs are real and often underexamined by people who are skilled at maintaining high performance regardless of what it requires.
A question worth sitting with: Is the life required to achieve this goal a life I actually want?
This is particularly relevant for professionals pursuing increasingly demanding roles largely because advancement feels like the obvious next step—not because they’ve deliberately chosen what comes next and why.
What Failure Can Reveal About What Success Means to You
Failure is uncomfortable. It’s also psychologically informative in ways that success often isn’t.
Setbacks can expose which outcomes genuinely mattered versus which were mostly about external validation. They reveal how much self-worth depends on achievement. They test which relationships remain supportive when status changes. And they create an opportunity—not always welcome, but real—to ask: What do I actually want to do next?
Embracing failure as part of a growth process, rather than evidence of permanent inadequacy, is one of the more durable forms of resilience available to high achievers. The way someone responds to a significant setback often shapes their trajectory more than the setback itself.
The more useful question after a failure is not only: “How quickly can I recover my previous status?”
It’s also: “What does this experience teach me about what actually matters?”
Helpful resource: Mayo Clinic — Resilience: Build Skills to Endure Hardship explains resilience as the ability to adapt to setbacks and difficult experiences and offers strategies involving connection, meaning, learning from experience, and taking constructive action.
Self-Discovery Is Not Just for People Who Are Lost
Self-discovery is not a crisis response. It’s an ongoing process—one that doesn’t end when someone reaches adulthood or professional success.
High-achieving people often spend years developing professional competence while investing far less attention in understanding their values, emotional needs, relational patterns, and what genuinely brings them joy or peace. This isn’t negligence. It’s a predictable outcome of spending formative years in systems that reward performance over reflection.
Someone does not need to be in crisis to reconsider fundamental questions about identity and meaning. In many cases, the people most capable of doing this work are those who have already proven they can accomplish difficult things—and are now ready to choose what comes next more deliberately.
Redefining Success Does Not Mean Lowering Your Standards
This point deserves direct attention, because it’s a common concern among high achievers.
“Redefine success” can sound like: stop being ambitious, care less about money, settle, expect less, work less. That is not the point.
A person may redefine success and become significantly more ambitious. The difference is that the ambition becomes intentional. Personal and professional goals that reflect genuine values tend to generate more sustainable motivation than goals inherited from external expectations—because the energy behind them is real.
The goal is not to strive less. It’s to strive toward outcomes that actually align with who you are and what you want your life to look like. That distinction changes everything about how achievement feels.
Contribution and Positive Impact as Measures of Success
For many accomplished people, success becomes more meaningful when it extends beyond accumulation.
Contributing positively—through mentoring, leadership, teaching, building something useful, supporting a community, or creating work that helps others—adds a dimension to success that purely personal achievement rarely provides. Positive impact doesn’t require a grand mission or public visibility. It can be quiet, relational, and deeply personal.
Impact might mean raising children with intention, supporting colleagues through difficult transitions, building a business that creates meaningful employment, or contributing to a community in ways that have nothing to do with professional recognition.
Asking “What am I contributing?” alongside “What am I accumulating?” can significantly expand the definition of a successful life.
Success Is a Journey, Not a Permanent Destination
A great deal of human suffering comes from the belief that life will finally feel right once some future condition is met.
- Once I graduate.
- Once I get hired.
- Once I make partner.
- Once I hit seven figures.
- Once I buy the house.
- Once I retire.
Every destination eventually becomes ordinary life. The sense of arrival fades. A new stage begins. This is not a bug in the human experience—it’s a feature. But it creates a real problem when psychological well-being depends entirely on reaching some future state.
Success is often better understood as an ongoing journey rather than a fixed destination. The question isn’t only “Will I eventually get there?” It’s “Do I want the life I’m living while pursuing the goal?”
The people who tend to experience the most sustainable sense of meaning are those who find something worthwhile in both the process and the outcome—not just the moment of arrival.
How Therapy Can Help You Define Success on Your Own Terms
Questions about success rarely exist in isolation. They overlap with deeper psychological themes: perfectionism, identity, family expectations, fear of failure, self-worth, burnout, relationship strain, and the anxiety that can accompany major life decisions.
For many highly accomplished people, the goal of therapy isn’t to function better. They already function exceptionally well. The more relevant questions are:
- What am I actually building with my life?
- Why does this matter to me—and does it still?
- Which patterns am I repeating that no longer serve me?
- How much of my identity depends on achievement?
- How do I create a life that works for me, rather than one that merely looks successful from the outside?
Dr. Matthew G. Mandelbaum’s approach at Groundbreaker Therapy combines clinical expertise with practical, real-world problem-solving. Drawing on Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT) and trauma-informed care, the work is tailored to each individual rather than applied through a standard formula. The focus is on psychological insight that translates into actual behavioral change—not just understanding patterns, but doing something different because of what you’ve learned.
Success Should Help You Build a Life You Actually Want
Achievement matters. Promotions, financial security, professional recognition, and ambitious goals can all be genuinely meaningful. The problem emerges when achievement becomes the sole measure of whether a life is going well—when it carries the full weight of identity, worth, and happiness.
Your definition of success can include achievement and financial security and meaningful relationships and personal growth and freedom and peace and work you actually care about. These are not competing categories. They can coexist—when someone takes the time to define what they want and build toward it deliberately.
And that definition can change. The version of success that drove you at 28 is allowed to evolve by 48. Recognizing that shift is not weakness. It is, in fact, one of the clearer signs of genuine growth.
Success is not simply reaching the next milestone. It is understanding what you are trying to build, why it matters, and whether the life required to reach it is one you actually want to live.
If you find yourself questioning achievement, career direction, identity, or what you want from the next chapter of your life, Groundbreaker Therapy may be the right place to explore those questions. Book a complimentary consultation with Dr. Mandelbaum today.
Frequently Asked Questions About Success
What is the true meaning of success?
There is no single true meaning. At its simplest, success is the accomplishment of an aim or purpose. But psychologically, a satisfying definition extends beyond accomplishment alone. For one person, success may mean financial security. For another, it may mean deep relationships, autonomy, meaningful work, personal growth, or peace. The most useful definition reflects individual values and the life someone genuinely wants to create—not a standard inherited from family, school, or professional culture.
What is success in 5 lines?
Success is achieving outcomes that genuinely matter to you. It can involve career, relationships, growth, financial security, contribution, or well-being. Success does not have one universal definition. Your definition may change as your life and priorities change. The most useful definition is one that reflects your values rather than someone else’s expectations.
What are 5 keys to success?
Rather than a universal formula, five psychological foundations tend to support a meaningful definition of success:
- Self-Awareness — Understanding what you actually value, not just what you’ve been taught to pursue.
- Clear Priorities — Knowing which personal and professional goals deserve your time and energy right now.
- Adaptability — Being willing to revise your definition as your life circumstances and values change.
- Meaningful Relationships — Recognizing that sustainable success rarely exists in isolation from other people.
- Sustainable Progress — Building a life that can support your ambitions without eroding your well-being in the process.
Other individuals may reasonably identify different foundations. The goal is to choose consciously rather than inherit by default.
What is success in the Bible?
Biblical interpretations of success vary across traditions and individual readers. Broadly, themes associated with a biblically informed understanding of a meaningful life often include faithfulness, wisdom, integrity, service to others, stewardship, and living according to spiritual values. For someone whose faith is central to their identity, religious beliefs can be an important source of core values and a meaningful framework for defining a well-lived life. That perspective deserves genuine consideration alongside professional and personal ambitions.
Why does achievement feel empty even when things are going well?
Achievement tends to produce temporary relief or satisfaction rather than permanent fulfillment—especially when the goal was pursued primarily to meet external expectations. When someone achieves something significant and notices a surprising absence of feeling, it often signals a gap between the life they’ve built and the values they actually hold. This experience is common among high-achieving individuals and is worth examining carefully rather than pushing past it toward the next goal.
How do I know if my definition of success needs to change?
Several signals are worth paying attention to: feeling chronically unsatisfied despite external markers of success, difficulty identifying what you actually want next, persistent burnout without a clear cause, or a growing sense that your work and life feel disconnected from what genuinely matters to you. These aren’t signs of failure—they’re invitations to reflect more honestly on what success means for you at this stage of your life.